DANGAL (Hindi, 2016)

Posted: August 17, 2017 in Cinema techniques, Hindi films

On Independence day I saw the money-spinner and much feted blockbuster film of recent years – DANGAL. Based on a true story, it is basically a tale of triumph of the human spirit against all prevalent societal norms seen through the story of a stern once-upon-a-time wrestler father (Amir Khan)  who toils hard after his two daughters since their childhood to make them top-notch wrestlers – something unthinkable of in a patriarchal Hariyanvi society. Quite an inspirational tale – every countryman should know and get influenced positively…

Did I like the film? I would have to reply in the negative at this self posed query. Why? … I felt that this three hour long biographical sports film could have been far more effective as a 30-40 minutes documentary. Sustaining interest in a film for three hours can be a challenge for the viewers and unless you have made a SHOLAY (to give an Indian example) it is bound to disappoint. Even Martin Scorcese’s brilliant biographical sports film RAGING BULL with a superlative performance by Robert De Niro had a running time of two hours. In that film there were sub-texts of personal problems of the protagonist boxer with his wife and his brother woven into the narrative to make it cinematic. DANGAL goes on and on about training sessions and the brooding father’s often uncompromising persona acts as a killjoy, making the film a far from pleasurable experience.

Rating: 2.8 out of 5

An exchange with my friend on FB:

Gaurav Dey Purkayastha Actually I read in an interview with one of the daughters that the film barely portrayed a fraction of what the sisters had to go through. Unlike you, however, I think this movie is a tour de force for Amir Khan’s acting.

Remove

Subhajit Ghosh
Subhajit Ghosh This is a personal opinion..
The huge popularity of the film and the glowing press it received certainly puts me in a minority

Manage

Subhajit Ghosh
Subhajit Ghosh Gaurav
As a film buff I am intrigued by the question ‘What makes a ‘great’ film’? I feel if you have to tell a great story, write a book. If you want wider reach (which btw all of us do) use the medium of TV. And these days you also have the web to reach everyone across the globe.
IMHO the best of cinema need to incorporate newer devices and innovate story-telling mechanism to make it engaging. When a Kurasawa re-creates a Shakespeare or Satyajit Ray makes a film on Tagore they incorporate ‘their’ thinking into such stories. I hear that the director of DANGAL changed the ‘climax’ from the original story. This is just to make it more melodramatic …
Actually my preference in films (Fellini, Chaplin & the early Mrinal Sen & …) have generally been those ones which tells good stories through innovate methods and humor. To give a Bollywood example, I hugely enjoyed Dibakar Bannerjee’s first film KHOSLA KA GHOSLA …
Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s